Miley and Kat (from Vampire Diaries fame, by the way) prove what a difference a little tailoring and accessorising can make to a dress.

We're not so keen on the collar effect happening on Miley's dress, but we're not loving Kat's shoes either (the dress is too busy for embellished ankle boots).

And while we're loving the fit and length of Miley's frock, Kat's just doesn't fit as well. Also, her hair should have been worn up, to show off the dramatic dress.

Overall, we're gonna go with Miley on this one...

Images: Getty

Who is your winner?