Share

Mr Wrong

Most of us have been through a phase of choosing completely unsuitable partners. But why is it that some of us have never grown out of picking the wrong men?

Here are some of the common issues that cause this vicious cycle:

The fear of being alone
Mallaby says there could be unaddressed abandonment issues, stemming from childhood. "Perhaps your parents divorced, or one died when you were young – this would explain why you are afraid of being left alone."

Societal pressure may be another factor. Although society is more tolerant now of women who marry later, or not at all, we are still saddled with ageing labels like "old maid" or "spinster" when we are single and independent adults. (Vastly less sexy than the eternal and rather distinguished "bachelor" for a man.)

Not to mention nagging relatives who want to know why aren't we married yet, and when are we going to find ourselves a "nice man to settle down with."

Apart from the enormous fun single women have and the independence they enjoy, a good man, frankly, is hard to find. But society makes us feel like less of a success if we take our time looking, or indeed choose the single life over coupledom.

Not only is society intolerant of singles, but it rather unrealistically romanticises the very idea of partnership. "The proverbial knight in shining armour, the notion of a soulmate, The One, or Mr Right, is a lot of BS!" says Mallaby.

All of these factors may distort a woman's idea of what a normal, healthy relationship is.

Resolving the past
Mallaby suggests that if you had an absent father, you could be replicating the childhood environment so you end up choosing someone who is emotionally unavailable and largely absent (just like your dad was). This is often the case with women who date married men.

"Although she keeps repeating the same pattern, her expectation is that at some stage the outcome will be different; when this man leaves his wife for her, it will validate her, and mean that she is in fact worthy of his love."

Because such a resolution is unlikely with the men they choose, these women are just denying themselves satisfying and mutually rewarding relationships.

Similarly, in abusive relationships (whether emotionally, verbally, psychologically or physically/ sexually), it's often a case of one partner trying to resolve a past problem.

"We go into fix or rescue mode. There is a deep-seated need to right the wrongs of the past, and that's why women stay in abusive relationships. They won't leave until the situation (or partner) is 'fixed'," says Mallaby.

But instead of giving a woman the power over past hurts that she is seeking, this kind of relationship erodes her sense of self-worth.

Reverting to the familiar
For women who are used to unfulfilling relationships, choosing wrong partner after wrong partner feels right because it's familiar. It's the way it's always been.

In this context, there is more than a little truth to the saying that women choose husbands who are like their fathers.

"It's like a dance," says Mallaby, you are used to one type of partner, you know your steps and those your partner takes. So you look for someone who can fill that mould, someone who can step into those shoes and lead you in the same way you know and are used to."

But, she warns, "It's not necessarily healthy, and you can't see this until you are aware of that role, and can learn alternative, more healthy dance steps."

The same can be said of men who choose wives who are like their mothers. Conditioning or programming is an extremely strong factor in determining our approach to rela­tionships. "This is why the 'inner child's perspective' used in therapy is so important.

"You have to understand the root cause of the behaviour of seeking out certain types of men, and bring it into adult awareness," says Mallaby.

Self-esteem
This is so often at the heart of unsatisfactory and abusive relationships. "In many cases, early negative experiences in relationships with significant others leads to self-esteem issues," confirms Mallaby. This makes us vulnerable to future destructive relationships.

Essentially, one has to develop a relationship with oneself based on forgiveness, acceptance and nurturing. "Too many young women are incredibly critical of themselves, often going into 'critical parent' mode.

"They don't believe anyone would want to be with them, and feel they have to put on a façade, afraid that if they show their vulnerability they will once again be rejected.

"We therefore tolerate abusive behaviour — all too often feeling responsible for or deserving of it. This only leads to a cycle of abuse that further erodes self-worth.

"The first step is identifying this cycle and gradually challenging some of these entrenched beliefs of ourselves as 'unlovable'," says Mallaby.

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
Who we choose to trust can have a profound impact on our lives. Join thousands of devoted South Africans who look to News24 to bring them news they can trust every day. As we celebrate 25 years, become a News24 subscriber as we strive to keep you informed, inspired and empowered.
Join News24 today
heading
description
username
Show Comments ()
Editorial feedback and complaints

Contact the public editor with feedback for our journalists, complaints, queries or suggestions about articles on News24.

LEARN MORE