Ethics brought into question as Nomuzi IG Live staged car accident is confirmed as part of a road safety campaign
The media and several social media users are asking a lot of questions after local TV personality Nomuzi 'Moozlie' Mabena's car seemingly crashes during an an Instagram Live video that went viral shortly after, leaving South Africans shocked, concerned and triggered last night.
Warning: Sensitive content
That video is so disturbing... I’m literally shaking. I hope Nomuzi is safe and ok??.— Terry Pheto (@TerryPheto) January 10, 2019
According to Channel24's The Juice, Moozlie's PR team "refused to comment [on the matter], saying that a statement would be released concerning the matter."
"Another member of Nomuzi's PR team, Kim Seneke, told The Juice they have been unsuccessful in attempts to reach the star, saying: "At this stage we're still trying to find out information." Seneke added that she had not heard from Nomuzi's family either," Channel24 reported this morning.
In the meantime, amidst genuine national concern about Moozlie's life and well-being, other speculations continued to be a talking point on social media - is this an Arrive Alive or Drive Dry campaign and was the fact that Nomuzi documented her whole evening all part of the act?
If this is the case (which we soon found out is), are the likes of organisations such as Drive Dry absolutely at their wit's end when they conceptualised their latest alleged shock value campaign advocating for responsible driving? Was this the last attempt at trying to get through to South Africans about their irresponsible driving habits? And has outrage marketing taken it too far?
This morning at 7:58, Twitter user @AdvBarryRoux posted a screenshot of a campaign draft last edited in March 2018, detailing how this alleged campaign would play out. The account has since been suspended.
Twitter remained divided over the crash and the consequences thereof for the better half of the day - whether real or a campaign:
Y’all ever thought about how we were probably the first people to find out about Nomuzi’s accident before her parents & loved ones, all because of social media?— Neo Sukude (@neo_sukude) January 10, 2019
Nomuzi can be wrong and still deserve kindness...you guise know that that’s possible right? Because she could be hurt. But go off with your self-righteousness.— Handsome Mable (@Mable__James) January 10, 2019
If that accident was staged, I’m definitely canceling Nomuzi. Can’t play with people’s emotions like that.— Baby ?? (@MimiSuna) January 10, 2019
I hope this wasn’t a publicity stunt.— ??Miss Radebe?????? (@tholakele15) January 11, 2019
South African celebrities should draw a line if is,some things are not funny,especially to people who have lost their love ones on the roads.
And people who have been involved on road accidents and sustained bad injuries.#Nomuzi
Addressing the insensitive approach
The main argument that has come the fore over conflicting reports on the rapper's accident is that if this is indeed a campaign for responsible driving, it has been executed irresponsibly.
Ever since society became vocally conscious about social issues, it seems a tactless marketing approach brands have employed is that of provoking and tugging at woke strings to gain attention for themselves.
It's the clickbait equivalent of marketing.
Sometimes they genuinely are misguided due to lack of representation on brand teams, but more often than not, it seems intentional.
And considering road accident deaths in our country are a grave matter that has devastated many families, a media ploy such as this alleged one is in extremely bad taste.
Yes, we have all been preaching the good word against texting and driving as well as drinking and driving. And while several drivers continue to ignore it, this approach was not the high note you were thought you were hitting at the end of the song you've been singing about safe driving.
We reached out to a SADAG trauma and mental health representative, Rutendo Shumba, who shared how the media affects individuals who suffer from PTSD.
"Post traumatic stress disorder can be the result of any terrifying incident you have experienced - from a robbery to childbirth to a car accident. You are constantly reminded of the event in your head and it even plays out in nightmares," she explains.
Rutendo says that if you have PTSD, you usually only want to acknowledge your trauma on your own terms. However, the media inadvertently breaches those terms by portraying sensitive or violent imagery to viewers; hence sensitivity warnings, which last night's video did not have.
Being confronted with violence and emotionally distressing content in the media in a bid to "create awareness" therefore does not aid the healing process, as Rutendo notes, "it's not happening on your terms. It's on someone else's terms and that's not healing."
She further tells us that psychologists usually recommend that their PTSD patients avoid media showing violence and crime if possible.
"In the case where it's not possible to do so," like an IG Live video of a celebrity you follow, "cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is prescribed. It helps you become desensitised to what is triggering you."
Government facilities do not offer CBT, so only those who have the funds for it have access to it.
For those who are not yet desensitised and are usually empathetic, as was seen through the #PrayforNomuzi hashtag, publicity stunts of this or a similar nature have a great potential to numb the more you get exposed to them.
As Rutendo observes, "daily news already desentise a lot of people and reduces one's level of empathy," so content displaying car accidents and other gruesome events is bound to heighten your inability to empathise.
Mass apathy would yield the opposite of the intended outcome of responsible driving and other social justice campaigns, so the mind boggles at how shock tactics seem to be considered most effective.
I partnered with @Volkswagen and @DriveDry to make a change in 2019. We don’t want to see another year where thousands of lives are lost on our roads because of drinking & driving.— #MoozlieVictory?? (@NoMoozlie) January 11, 2019
Take the pledge and make the change to #VWDriveDry in 2019. #Nomuzihttps://t.co/HsxMlIBjQr
Volkswagen SA also confirmed the campaign on their Twitter account and the #VWDriveDry hashtag has already gained traction on social media with a number of mixed feelings and criticism.
What has the internet even more upset is how in the official ad, VW shows their numbers and social media reactions - genuine concerns of supporters - to boast of how "successful" the campaign rollout was.
We understand social media is one of the most impactful tools to get through to our generation, but to say this was insensitive would be an understatement.
We will update with further comment from Drive Dry, VW and Nomuzi.
* This article was updated to reflect the confirmation that the car crash was staged.
Sign up to W24’s newsletters so you don't miss out on any of our hot stories and giveaways.